- March 29, 2026
-
Re: notes from the day
Thanks Bojana it's useful to read so quickly what you caught of the conversations yesterday, and I have a sense that more was articulated than perhaps we thought in the aftermath of Gillie's 'academic' comment. I caught a few other notes which I'll send this morning if I have time and otherwise later this week.
I woke this morning thinking that it's perhaps necessary this morning to risk a motivation beyond the awareness of the scientific concepts, so I propose beginning with a creative motivation given by me which clarifies the context as being 'a dance workshop'. This may then situate the research questions in a less academic place and give us a sense how that differs from the more specifically science focussed tasks.
Having said that though, I would repeat my comment of yesterday that a different tone of conversation arises from the risk to focus away from creative motivation. Does it matter then that it feels less comfortable for the dancer? I would argue that they will take away with them tools to rethink what the're doing which will have a slower impact than the two days can immediately offer, but perhaps we need to test this with follow up communication over the next month or so?
Jonathan
On Sat, 28 Mar 2026 at 23:36, Bojana Cvejic <bojanacvejic@gmail.com> wrote:In the preparation of the day, Guido asks what might be missing from Krakauer’s theory:
-
Motivation – extrinsic (sports: functional, scoring) and intrinsic (artistic: aesthetic criteria)
-
Metacognition – another process of awareness, similar to self-reflection, which includes observing how one get better at motor learning: more sensitive, more apt, motorically etc.
-
The feeling of one performing before an audience
Jonathan: I belong to those performers who avoids self-consciousness
Bojana: why you practice folk music
Guido: There is always consciousness, but the question is about traning what you are paying attention to
Jonathan: What if everyone who dances is already creating choreography? Warning from Chrysa: dancers might not agree to this equation; those who don’t identify with being a choreographer, but an artist
Suba: on the question of music: although Indian classical dance is identified with music, music is not always the source of movement; in working with different social groups from Bharatanatyam and Kathak, for example with people with dementia, the motivation was feeling, storytelling, etc. in order to perform gesture
Jonathan: “gesture” might be another object of study that we haven’t thought of
Guido’s lecture: “What do dancers do when they dance?”
Cognitive and discrete elements: the knowledge that you can put into words
The sensorimotor – how I perceive and move;
as a knowledge it cannot be adequately verbalized, the words are not sufficient, you have to do it to learn it, acquire skill
the part of it that is accessible, that is, can be put into words: procedural knowledge
the part that isn’t accessible as such is the continuous, because you can’t easily say where it starts and ends
the cognitive and the sensorimotor are considered to be a binary
awareness isn’t binary, but a spectrum, a matter of different degrees
on the bottom left: cognitive, discrete but implicit, inaccessible > knowledge that could be put into words but isn’t readily available, we are not aware of the bias because of forgetting (e.g. a series of actions you learnt and you could verbalize it if you haven’t forgotten them)
the cognitive, declarative, discrete but implicit and inaccessible (the bottom left) is so ingrained and therefore difficult to change (e.g. we become aware of it through unsuccessful attempts to change against it) > culture as an inevitable default
for example, the bias of gender; another example, what appears in improvisation as set, part of default, while it is not perceived by the dancer as such (for example, the amalgamation of many modern dance techniques in Steve Paxton’s improvisation)
Suba: there is no improvisation in the Western sense in Bharatanatyam or Kathak, everything is codified and the dancer learns to master movements
Bojana: is it about a scale of variation that is negotiable within this classical form?
Suba: yes, on two levels: it is either individual, dependent on training with a teacher, or deliberate, a matter of interpretation (which amounts to a combinatory)
Guido: In cultural transmission, learning goes through copying the explicit, cognitive and deliberate, and the individual sensorimotor, continuous and explicit must become cognitive to be available for emulation
Bojana: what we learnt from the neuroanthropologist Gregg Downey is that the implicit, cognitive – for example, the style of behavior of the teacher in capoeira, the social practice of roda – also partakes of cultural transmission
Part of the implicit is your autobiography, something that congeals into the nebulous background
To conclude, the bottom left includes: bias, default, autobiography, contex, culture
Guido: the “dual process theory” – thinking/learning&acquiring/forgetting fast/slow applies to these four distinctions
We learn fast, forget fast and remember slow: the cognitive, declarative, discrete
Possibly, the implicit and inaccessible within the cognitive, declarative, discrete might be slower to both form and dissipate; you accumulate knowledge over lifetime
Guido: strangely enough, dance only recognizes the existence of these two in opposition:
The top left: cognitive/declarative/discrete + explicit/deliberate/accessible
Top bottom right: sensorimotor/procedural/continuous + implicit/automatic/inaccessible
Jonathan's preference for dancing without self-consciousness finds itself situated between the other two cateogies (cognitive, discrete, implicit and sensorimotor, procedural, explicit, accessible)
After the first task:
Gillie: I wasn’t warmed up, so the dancing I did amounted to an execution of warm-up “seasoning the space”. I noticed I have the habit of going to the floor and stretching hips. I am seeking sensation.
I rememebred that in the community dance froup I am conducting, we are five, we have this work of “making a portrait”; one person leaves the room and the remaining four make a portrait of her; they took a piss out of me and portrayed me with “slow dance”, something I like to do and ask of them and they dislike it
In this task, I didn’t know what to do. I became aware of repeating six-sevent units of action, something that occurs as opening syntax. Normally I am not concerned with whether this is dance or not, now I was
Suba: I worked with jathi – eight-rhythm cycle from slow to fast, and with faster tempo it gets more complex, concluding in a flourishing rhythm; there is a distinct beginning and ending to it
I observed two things:
1)
Structure made me feel an urge to shift, and I was wondering whether playfulness resulted from the context; or because I master it in this context I have this overwhelming urge to play with it2)
I realied that the skeletal structure of the rhythm gives me confidence to shift and change; I could even give myself paramters for shifting, and this included:-
Speed of the movement, slowing down to get the feeling of it
-
Being low in the ground
Jonathan: is ther ea sense of wanting to change when tou know something well?
Gillie: the most familiar stays unremarkable
Suba: perhaps change was possible because I am so confident about this sequence
Gillie: it is possible to move from the cognitive…inaccessible to the cognitive…accessible – like in my example of the hips habit – the frame of the task enabled me to realize it
Intuition is the movement from bottom (inaccessible) up (accessible); a “delayed cognition” when something which wasn’t remarked before suddenly crystallizes
Guido: for cultural transmission (“teaching”), if you are going to start from your own movement, then this movement has to shift from the right to the left
Bojana: Forsythe has done that, because in his solo we understand that he is far beyond the improvisation technologies which he developed with and for his dancers, who have a background in ballet; but he had to make it explicit, cognitive, declarative and deliberate knowledge through geometry, drawing lines and figures and writing with the body
Forsythe counts on two types of knowledge in the implicit and inaccessible lower region: the sensorimotor reflexes of ballet-trained dancers and their ballet bias (computation of images)
His method movs from the bottom right to bottom left to top left to top right
Clockwise movement
In Ingold’s theory of educating attention, motor learning goes from the bottom right to the top right
Guido: the top right is where stage presence is situated
Bojana: virtuosity, capacity to bring good decisions in the moment because of accumulated knowledge
Gillie: the example of driving entails moving from the top left to the top right to the bottom right to the bottom left
Suba: these categories in the four quadrants might happen universally in dancing (Guido: species-specific) but are they explored in the classical form of nonWestern dance like the Indian classical dance? Perhaps in other terms and questions, they might be motivated differently, for example, in Bharatanatyam expression might be the reason
Guido: in Western dance, habit and skill have a peculiar relationship; habit is the negatively valenced skill
Bojana: how would somatic approach make its trajectory through the four categories? Counterclockwise; it starts from the sensorimotor implicit and inaccessible as the locus of truth, the real that is spontaneous that crops up in a somatic exploration; thanks to the somatic techniqe it becomes sensorimotor continuous accessible (procedural knowledge), which then can move to the cognitive concepts
Looking at the quadrants again in light of dance:
You become aware of the reflex indirectly – by resistance through error, inertia to change
Motor learning is on the right side and equals to forming habit
Suba: I am taught to be aware and control the image of every little bit of my body for the viewer, to project the slightest detail to the viewer
Bojana: difference in comparison with the dancer’s agency in Western tradition (shifting away from the visual, ocular, the image into the feeling and sensation); your agency is in the control of the image, its projection
Jonathan: do the same four categories apply to the audinece?
Response to the second task:
Suba: my instinct was to move freely and to have eliminated all parameters (such as speed, space, rhythm); this was a delibearte decision; but very quickly onwards I noticed how structuring elements from Bharatanatyam crept in, like symmetry, and I would have to consciously undo them, this was a matter of explicit and deliberate decisions.
Something else happened with gestures; while dancing freely I felt strange that I wasn’t doing everything with my fingers; gestures appeared and disappeared without me having to actively undo them.
The freedom I gave myself made it more difficult to return to the phrase and explore it more
The context was missing
Bojana: could our method be to continue to query your practice with some of these questions in the context of your practice?
Gillie: what I recognizes as reflex was to correct balance ad pain. Every time I recognized a pattern, I would amplify it. I struggled to escape the overlap between the four.
| | | | | | | | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | | | Text Box: 30/30/35/20 | | Text Box: 30/20/20/20 | | | | | | | | | | | | Text Box: 20/30/22,5/50 | | | | Text Box: 20/20/22,5/10 | | | |
-
- March 28, 2026
-
notes from the day
In the preparation of the day, Guido asks what might be missing from Krakauer’s theory:
- Motivation – extrinsic (sports: functional, scoring) and intrinsic (artistic: aesthetic criteria)
- Metacognition – another process of awareness, similar to self-reflection, which includes observing how one get better at motor learning: more sensitive, more apt, motorically etc.
- The feeling of one performing before an audience
Jonathan: I belong to those performers who avoids self-consciousness
Bojana: why you practice folk music
Guido: There is always consciousness, but the question is about traning what you are paying attention to
Jonathan: What if everyone who dances is already creating choreography? Warning from Chrysa: dancers might not agree to this equation; those who don’t identify with being a choreographer, but an artist
Suba: on the question of music: although Indian classical dance is identified with music, music is not always the source of movement; in working with different social groups from Bharatanatyam and Kathak, for example with people with dementia, the motivation was feeling, storytelling, etc. in order to perform gesture
Jonathan: “gesture” might be another object of study that we haven’t thought of
Guido’s lecture: “What do dancers do when they dance?”
Cognitive and discrete elements: the knowledge that you can put into words
The sensorimotor – how I perceive and move;
as a knowledge it cannot be adequately verbalized, the words are not sufficient, you have to do it to learn it, acquire skill
the part of it that is accessible, that is, can be put into words: procedural knowledge
the part that isn’t accessible as such is the continuous, because you can’t easily say where it starts and ends
the cognitive and the sensorimotor are considered to be a binary
awareness isn’t binary, but a spectrum, a matter of different degrees
on the bottom left: cognitive, discrete but implicit, inaccessible > knowledge that could be put into words but isn’t readily available, we are not aware of the bias because of forgetting (e.g. a series of actions you learnt and you could verbalize it if you haven’t forgotten them)
the cognitive, declarative, discrete but implicit and inaccessible (the bottom left) is so ingrained and therefore difficult to change (e.g. we become aware of it through unsuccessful attempts to change against it) > culture as an inevitable default
for example, the bias of gender; another example, what appears in improvisation as set, part of default, while it is not perceived by the dancer as such (for example, the amalgamation of many modern dance techniques in Steve Paxton’s improvisation)
Suba: there is no improvisation in the Western sense in Bharatanatyam or Kathak, everything is codified and the dancer learns to master movements
Bojana: is it about a scale of variation that is negotiable within this classical form?
Suba: yes, on two levels: it is either individual, dependent on training with a teacher, or deliberate, a matter of interpretation (which amounts to a combinatory)
Guido: In cultural transmission, learning goes through copying the explicit, cognitive and deliberate, and the individual sensorimotor, continuous and explicit must become cognitive to be available for emulation
Bojana: what we learnt from the neuroanthropologist Gregg Downey is that the implicit, cognitive – for example, the style of behavior of the teacher in capoeira, the social practice of roda – also partakes of cultural transmission
Part of the implicit is your autobiography, something that congeals into the nebulous background
To conclude, the bottom left includes: bias, default, autobiography, contex, culture
Guido: the “dual process theory” – thinking/learning&acquiring/forgetting fast/slow applies to these four distinctions
We learn fast, forget fast and remember slow: the cognitive, declarative, discrete
Possibly, the implicit and inaccessible within the cognitive, declarative, discrete might be slower to both form and dissipate; you accumulate knowledge over lifetime
Guido: strangely enough, dance only recognizes the existence of these two in opposition:
The top left: cognitive/declarative/discrete + explicit/deliberate/accessible
Top bottom right: sensorimotor/procedural/continuous + implicit/automatic/inaccessible
Jonathan's preference for dancing without self-consciousness finds itself situated between the other two cateogies (cognitive, discrete, implicit and sensorimotor, procedural, explicit, accessible)
After the first task:
Gillie: I wasn’t warmed up, so the dancing I did amounted to an execution of warm-up “seasoning the space”. I noticed I have the habit of going to the floor and stretching hips. I am seeking sensation.
I rememebred that in the community dance froup I am conducting, we are five, we have this work of “making a portrait”; one person leaves the room and the remaining four make a portrait of her; they took a piss out of me and portrayed me with “slow dance”, something I like to do and ask of them and they dislike it
In this task, I didn’t know what to do. I became aware of repeating six-sevent units of action, something that occurs as opening syntax. Normally I am not concerned with whether this is dance or not, now I was
Suba: I worked with jathi – eight-rhythm cycle from slow to fast, and with faster tempo it gets more complex, concluding in a flourishing rhythm; there is a distinct beginning and ending to it
I observed two things:
1)
Structure made me feel an urge to shift, and I was wondering whether playfulness resulted from the context; or because I master it in this context I have this overwhelming urge to play with it2)
I realied that the skeletal structure of the rhythm gives me confidence to shift and change; I could even give myself paramters for shifting, and this included:- Speed of the movement, slowing down to get the feeling of it
- Being low in the ground
Jonathan: is ther ea sense of wanting to change when tou know something well?
Gillie: the most familiar stays unremarkable
Suba: perhaps change was possible because I am so confident about this sequence
Gillie: it is possible to move from the cognitive…inaccessible to the cognitive…accessible – like in my example of the hips habit – the frame of the task enabled me to realize it
Intuition is the movement from bottom (inaccessible) up (accessible); a “delayed cognition” when something which wasn’t remarked before suddenly crystallizes
Guido: for cultural transmission (“teaching”), if you are going to start from your own movement, then this movement has to shift from the right to the left
Bojana: Forsythe has done that, because in his solo we understand that he is far beyond the improvisation technologies which he developed with and for his dancers, who have a background in ballet; but he had to make it explicit, cognitive, declarative and deliberate knowledge through geometry, drawing lines and figures and writing with the body
Forsythe counts on two types of knowledge in the implicit and inaccessible lower region: the sensorimotor reflexes of ballet-trained dancers and their ballet bias (computation of images)
His method movs from the bottom right to bottom left to top left to top right
Clockwise movement
In Ingold’s theory of educating attention, motor learning goes from the bottom right to the top right
Guido: the top right is where stage presence is situated
Bojana: virtuosity, capacity to bring good decisions in the moment because of accumulated knowledge
Gillie: the example of driving entails moving from the top left to the top right to the bottom right to the bottom left
Suba: these categories in the four quadrants might happen universally in dancing (Guido: species-specific) but are they explored in the classical form of nonWestern dance like the Indian classical dance? Perhaps in other terms and questions, they might be motivated differently, for example, in Bharatanatyam expression might be the reason
Guido: in Western dance, habit and skill have a peculiar relationship; habit is the negatively valenced skill
Bojana: how would somatic approach make its trajectory through the four categories? Counterclockwise; it starts from the sensorimotor implicit and inaccessible as the locus of truth, the real that is spontaneous that crops up in a somatic exploration; thanks to the somatic techniqe it becomes sensorimotor continuous accessible (procedural knowledge), which then can move to the cognitive concepts
Looking at the quadrants again in light of dance:
You become aware of the reflex indirectly – by resistance through error, inertia to change
Motor learning is on the right side and equals to forming habit
Suba: I am taught to be aware and control the image of every little bit of my body for the viewer, to project the slightest detail to the viewer
Bojana: difference in comparison with the dancer’s agency in Western tradition (shifting away from the visual, ocular, the image into the feeling and sensation); your agency is in the control of the image, its projection
Jonathan: do the same four categories apply to the audinece?
Response to the second task:
Suba: my instinct was to move freely and to have eliminated all parameters (such as speed, space, rhythm); this was a delibearte decision; but very quickly onwards I noticed how structuring elements from Bharatanatyam crept in, like symmetry, and I would have to consciously undo them, this was a matter of explicit and deliberate decisions.
Something else happened with gestures; while dancing freely I felt strange that I wasn’t doing everything with my fingers; gestures appeared and disappeared without me having to actively undo them.
The freedom I gave myself made it more difficult to return to the phrase and explore it more
The context was missing
Bojana: could our method be to continue to query your practice with some of these questions in the context of your practice?
Gillie: what I recognizes as reflex was to correct balance ad pain. Every time I recognized a pattern, I would amplify it. I struggled to escape the overlap between the four.
| | | | | | | | | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | | | | Text Box: 30/30/35/20 | | Text Box: 30/20/20/20 | | | | | | | | | | | | Text Box: 20/30/22,5/50 | | | | Text Box: 20/20/22,5/10 | | | |
- March 12, 2026
-
(no subject)
FROM JONATHAN: SOME NOTES ON KRAKAUER MOTOR LEARNING PAPER 12TH MARCH 2026.
Here are some key concepts that seemed relevant to the Rethinking Choreography research (Guido you can maybe unpack these for us a bit, or point us towards other concepts I may have missed?):
Explicit or implicit learning (neuroscientists differ in opinion over whether motor learning of sequences is primarily implicit or explicit (cognitive); explicit contributions occur more in early learning and in more complex sequences; implicit learning that arises may simply be the automatization of an explicitly learned element order; practice leads to a reduction in the cognitive load associated with the task)
Faster and slower learning (slower learning lasts longer)
Improvements in performance (can also occur between practice sessions)
Higher level representation of sequence (abstract representation of sequence order forms as sequence is learned)
Continuous sequential actions (continuous single movements are comprised of sequential sub-elements)
Chunk structures (limit of number of individual movements that can be grouped into a single set; chunking begins with learning transitions between 2 movements; once learned the initial movement triggers the entire chunk; wrongly learned chunks that interrupt a run of optimum transitions remain despite long practice of improved version; chunking is currently understood as cognitive rather than motor learning)
Adaption (adaption as quicker then motor learning, but more transient)
Savings (adapting faster when meeting the same pertubation)
Sensory prediction (can alter future reactions if the expected consequence is different than expected)
Motor variability (even in a situation of perfect execution, this variability anticipates future error)
Retrograde interference (the learning of B interferes with the memory of previously adapting to A)
Interaction between two actions (second action updated to account for anticipated or observed spatial errors in the first action)
Generalization (examines the ability to transfer learned performance improvements to other effectors e.g., the other hand, or to novel but similar sequences: 'The finding that sequences can generalize provides evidence that representations of entire sequences are not movement-specific. This is not surprising given the evidence reviewed in the previous section indicating that the constituent chunks comprising a sequence are already likely to be representations of order rather than continuous motor actions.'
And here a a few questions that emerge for me in relation to this paper:
The motor learning experiments described here are mostly based on functional sports or craft-like movements (reaching etc.). What, if any, difference might occur in the context of movement that carries a sense of pleasure in pattern, rhythm or expressive meaning? Aesthetic aspects are seen here as connected to cognition rather than motor learning. What might this distinction mean in relation to the performance of sequenced movement in dance?
Do the arguments for or against explicit or implicit motor learning, impact our reflections on memorised or improvised approaches to dance sequences?
What's the difference for the dancer between motor adaptability and aesthetic adaptability and how might they be entangled when we dance?
Does the arrival at an abstract representation of order in the process of 'generalisation', suggest some connection to the 'feeling' of choreography as separate from movement?
-
(no subject)
FROM JONATHAN: SOME NOTES FROM THE CONVERSATION WITH ADRIÁN YORIS 4TH FEBRUARY 2026.
Guido
We thought you'd be a good person to talk to for two reasons: dancers draw from somatic practice so are concerned with interoceptive experience, so I'd be interested to hear from a neuroscientific perspective as to what if anything you can feel; and that for me in the absence of an external musical rhythm that guides movement, dancers draw from internal rhythms.
Adrián
I can't help thinking about many things while Jonathan was introducing the topic. First of all the body has a choreography and everybody within movement has a specific choreography, we don't only have to think about dance.
A definition of the interoceptive: how the brain and body are connected and how that information is taken from the body. It makes me think of some studies in trauma for instance, where dance is used as a therapy to introduce changes at the level of memory. There's a connection between this research and how emotions are processed. How we are more accurate at detecting these signals in motion and use them in therapies.
One of the problems is how we measure interoceptive information. It has at least three sources of information: the heart, respiration and stomach. All of them come with methodological issues.
Bojana
I like when you make the link with emotions. This idea that everybody has a choreography also makes sense and it makes me think of social choreography. When I read your paper I wondered about whether hormones play a role? Dance is interested in pleasure hormones, and I wonder if dancers are imagining these affects?
Adrián
I should research on that to provide a proper answer, but stress hormones seem to affect interoceptive experience. However, they do this secretly, at a very slow pace. The stress hormones are particularly difficult to catch.
But you are not looking for a design at this point, it's a philosophical questioning at the moment.
Bojana
I like reading this in your paper that there is no robust evidence, which is bad news for the somaticians, but where are they getting the feelings from?
Adrián
The heart and respiration are connected by the autonomic system.
What happens when the signals are de-synchronised. This is interesting in terms of what a dancer feels in a repeating movement and so forth.
Guido
Normally you don't want to feel your interoceptive feelings, because you usually only do that when something is wrong.
Adrián
I've never found publications related to other organs than skin, heart, lungs, stomach.
However, my yoga practice that I do every week also asks that you tune into organs.
Bojana
The aesthetic expressions in somatic work are self-similar, to do with slowness and interior focus. It's eroded a sense of social liveness. It's become focussed on individuality. The interest in the motor paradigm is that it frees us from this introspection.
Adrián
Are you making a distinction between the anxiety of skilled dancing and the pleasure of 'just dancing'.
Guido
One interesting question for me is when the dancer intensively practices this somatic work over years, what are they becoming an expert in? Do they get better at perceiving their bodies, or do they get better at something else, for instance dual targeting their attention between themself and the outside world.
Adrián
I can share an image from cyclists: trained cyclists show the ability to be able to regulate exertion. During high demand those who have better experience in terms of regulating breathing have a better performance. This was related to the brain activity.
Jonathan
I think this does relate to dancers because dancers have used somatic practice to avoid injury by developing more efficient bodily use, which requires interoceptive sensitivity.
Adrián
I'm thinking also about pain. There's a gate theory of pain that says when the heart ejects blood to the blood stream there's a gate wherein nothing is felt even pain, but when blood pressure goes down is when most interoceptive information including pain is experienced. Also emotions showing in the face are related to this cycle.
Jonathan
Dancer talk about having a high pain threshold, so they're practicing to become more aware of interoceptive experience and at the same time blocking pain.
Bojana
I'd be interested in a dialogue between interoceptive understandings form dance and neuroscience.
Guido
I feel that aside from interoception as an experience, I'd like to understand these signals of breathing and heart as a source of felt choreography that provides a rhythm.
Jonathan
And the connection between interoception and sequencing.
Guido
The question is not whether somatic work changes something, it's whether it changes what was intended.
I feel like it might be good to talk to someone in meta-cognition (cognition about cognition as a mechanistic explanation to consciousness). For instance that what changes is not cognition, but how we deal with cognition.
Spinoza is still the groundwork for interoceptive research.
- February 16, 2026
-
Lauren Scott
FROM HIP HOP ARTIST LAUREN SCOTT: AN INTERESTING OBSERVATION ABOUT IMPROVISED OR LEARNED SEQUENCES 16TH FEBRUARY 2026.
Lauren
I also think there’s a lot to be gained from exploring how a freestyler’s brain handles set choreography compared to stimulus-led improvisation. To me, the internal 'feel' and processing of these two tasks is drastically different. It would be worth looking into whether this subjective difference correlates with the activation of distinct neural pathways or levels of cognitive load.
- January 31, 2026
-
From Jonathan
FROM JONATHAN: SOME NOTES FROM THE CONVERSATION ABOUT METAPHOR 8TH JANUARY 2026.
Bojana
I terms of the use of metaphor in dance and science, it's clear cognitive science has a take on metaphor (Lackoff and Johnson 'Metaphors we live by').
Guido
Lackoff and Johnson is about how embodied cognition is grounded in the body (up and down etc.), which is different from the way that metaphors are a way of explaining and understanding science (often dependent on current technology), so do we do one or both?
Bojana
Is it important to determine which of the approaches is doing what, somatic work is creating poetry deliberately and fiction, so how do we discern these two registers and we'd benefit more from the literal and park aside the deliberately figurative as poetry.
Guido
The usefulness of a metaphor from a scientific sense, does it obscure or reveal something? The metaphor 'mind as computer' reveals in terms of rhythms and neuros firing, but the problem is that what gets obscured is that computers don't have an incentive to live; the disembodied sense, the difference between software and hardware, which doesn't work in terms of the human body. In terms of bringing together dancers and neuroscientists, the scientists will say they're not interested in the metaphors, but you just have to find a way to talk about it. They're not much in a practice of reflecting.
Guido
'The Idea of the Brain' Matthew Cobb, maps out metaphors of the brain.
Bojana
There's a mistrust of language amongst dancers so they're covering up for that by becoming creative about language.
Guido
I think we've stumbled on a commonality, as neuroscientists are also sceptical of language as they believe in numbers.
Guido
When I have dance researchers present they enjoy the clarity of literal description of experiment, a decisiveness in the scientific use of language that doesn't happen in dance. But I try to make clear it's not about truth, it's just about what appears in that moment to be possible to state. You need to set that frame before you start.
Bojana
So the demonstration of proof is acceptable for dancers so they accept them as facts, but not as truths.
Guido
There are rabbit holes that are useful to go down. Things we need to agree upon before we walk into a situation. Can we reveal everything that goes on in our bodies? Probably not.
Bojana
We have to have a minimum of facts that inform a framework within which we enter a conversation.
Bojana
Sporadically somatic issues arose in previous research, but we fended it off. We somehow shared a sceptical approach.
Jonathan
And maybe this sceptical approach is something we can share between science and somatics, so we're not searching for truths.
FROM JONATHAN: NOTES FROM THE MEETING WITH KATJA KORNYSHEVA 30TH JANUARY 2026.
Re-reading the notes I managed to take I'm aware of a few subtly new perspectives that jump out for me:
- Katja's image of the gesture as not monolithic but rather flexible to conditions (this seems to echo Ingold).
- Guido's comment that 'movement is also an act of sequencing, and sequencing may always be an act of moving', which I think challenges common views of movement in dance.
- Katja's observation that learned movements embrace low level synergies as well as more sequenced manifestations (I have an image here of more faint impulses of motor memory when I dance, which offers a bridge between fixed phrases and the impulses of improvisation).
- Kayja's interest in the possibility of a link between interoceptive experience and the pre-ordering of movement.
- Her distinction between bodily space and navigational space.
Anyway here's what I caught and forgive me if I've misquoted or misheard either of you!
CONVERSATION:
Katja
I'm coming from a musicians point of view if anything.
Competitive queuing paper potentially suggests that the gesture is not monolithic, but that they're built in a modular way allowing for flexibility, and at the last minute. During the final hundreds of milliseconds before movement you have two things occurring, the sequence and at the same time the timing or rhythmic element, they're in parallel but not integrated, so they can flexibly move around before the movement is initiated. Once the movement is initiated there's less flexibility. At present we're not yet able to find an adequate representation of this moment just before.
Bojana
How dancers articulate these boundaries between conscious and non-conscious. Because of the shift of the motor paradigm we wanted to question this. For some practitioners they feel the need to hold onto the idea of spontaneity.
For me what's new in what you're saying is the positionality in the moment before the movement is made.
Guido
To bring neuroscience knowledge into dance practice. What dance lacks is a working definition of how it works and how we're talking about it. For dancers there's a separation between dance and choreography. A lot of problems arise when you put dance into a medical context, like Parkinson's, and it makes a huge difference whether you use spontaneous or learned movement.
Your work brings together memory, sequencing and motor control, and so brings together the choreographic and motor control aspects, which makes your work and perspective very relevant here. It indicates that movement is also an act of sequencing, and sequencing may always be an act of moving.
Katja
I didn't know this distinction between dance and choreography. I'm thinking carefully what we mean by a learnt repertoire, from really low level synergies to more sequencing of these synergies, which may or may not become a synergy themself.
Are you also looking at medical applications or clinical applications?
Bojana
What is perhaps unusual is that Jonathan suggested a panoply of different dance forms.
For some people what we propose is confronting, in terms of the difference between improvisation and choreography.
Katja
I haven't made a link to interoceptive experience, but that could be related to the pre-ordering of movement. (Robert Hylton 'the bit before' and 'polysomatic' practice.
Guido
We're not doing any experiments, it's about data from conversations. I do see us producing a number of conceptual papers on motor control and sequencing which don't currently exist in dance neuroscience.
Katja
I've been integrating in anecdotal form about how this affects practice, particularly in relation to music, but I've never had the bandwidth to talk to musicians properly and initiate that dialogue. I don't have intention to produce academic papers in this space, but it's an act of engagement that matters and something that serves as general outreach in a cross-sector way. A lot of what my lab does is technological and around surgical skills, like stroke rehab etc., but art is missing currently, so I'd be interested from that perspective. If you think more than that would be useful I'd be happy to explore.
We have worked with the Royal College of Music about breakdown of skills from a clinical perspective. I'd be interested in understanding.
Bojana
The difference between how Jonathan and Matteo move in Both Sitting Duet.
Guido
The question of what can a dancer be aware of. Dancers from somatic practice often imagine they're able to experience more interoceptive information than they'r capable of. At one point does conscious behaviour come in?
Katja
There's unpublished data where people have secondary tasks to perform and there are still markers of pre-conscious decision making. I'm happy to comment on this, but we're lacking experiments that look only at that.
Bojana
When you use the word representations what do you mean?
Katja
They're distributed across the brain, so it's a super fuzzy term. For me we have a pragmatic definition which is there is information in brain patterns which differentiate between the two.
One idea is if it's in the hypocampus it's distributed laterally, in intrinsic rather than bodily space. It's more akin to navigation than body memory.
There's a lot of pushback as these ideas contradict previous models.
Bojana
Would one say a temporary alignment that's not always located in the same place?
Katja
It can be quite consistent in terms of patterns, but they're not always located in the same place.
Bojana
In terms of memory we observed how performing sequences for some is visual and for some is like music.
Katja
In dance there's a much stronger aspect of navigation than in music.
Guido
But you could say it's always a path through space whether it's temporal or spatial.
- January 22, 2026
-
(no subject)
hi *, *, and *!
if you want to keep a thought or a bit of text, whether to work with together or simply to know where to find it, write to ****@******* and it will appear on keep.momey.org within the next 10 minutes. More precisely, it will be up shortly after an interval of 10 (e.g. 11:20 and 26 seconds).
you won't be able to send images. just text. and while formatting is possible, it is really designed for plain text.
time and date on the platform are rendered in UTC
best,
Austin